Curing Miracle Steps in LLM Mathematical Reasoning with Rubric Rewards

ArXi:2510.07774v3 Announce Type: replace In this paper, we observe that current models are susceptible to reward hacking, leading to a substantial overestimation of a model's reasoning ability. This is evidenced by a high incidence of false positives-solutions that reach the correct answer through an unsound process. Through a systematic analysis with human verification, we establish a taxonomy of these failure modes, identifying patterns like Miracle Steps-abrupt jumps to a correct output without a valid preceding derivation.